I’m confused Facebook… (Trigger warning)


I was temporarily blocked from Facebook on Wednesday, May 22, for posting this image on my AmazingWomenRock Facebook page in support of the open letter campaign jointly spearheaded by Women, Action, & Media (WAM), The Everyday Sexism Project and writer/activist Soraya Chemaly:

Tape her and rape her big

The image was removed from the AmazingWomenRock Facebook page in the early hours of Wednesday May 22.

When I tried to logon to Facebook I received this notice saying the image violates the Facebook community standards:facebook-removed tape her

This morning, May 25, members of the Twitter community alerted me to the fact that the image was still on the page (Offensive Humor at Its Best), where it was originally posted in February.

I made this comment on the Offensive Humor at Its Best post (Susan notes: the image and the page were taken down sometime in the two hours following this post going live – a tiny victory in a much bigger war. However, there are thousands more to go. WAM captures new images here on a regula basis):

Susan Macaulay: Hey Facebook! This content was removed from my page and you blocked me for posting it saying it does not conform to your community standards. Question: Why is it OK for it to appear here and not OK for me to post it on my page in protest of it appearing here? #justasking Unlike · Reply · 1 · 4 minutes ago Saturday May 25, 07:52

Then I reported the post per Facebook’s procedure. Twice. Once as “hate speech,” once as “nudity or pornography.”

Facebook responded within seconds, both times with the following auto response:

FB reprt 3

Since then, dozens, maybe even hundreds, of people have reported the image on the Offensive Humor page.

And yet, as of 4:17 pm on Saturday May 25, it remains there (Susan notes: it was taken down shortly after this post went live), despite it having been removed from my page (where I had run it in protest with a link to the open letter campaign). Facebook removed the image from my page and blocked me, because, according to Facebook, I had violated their community standards for posting it.

I’m confused. My question for Facebook remains:

Why does this image, which you removed from my page and for which I was temporarily blocked from Facebook, remain up on a page (which boldly calls itself offensive), despite having been repeatedly reported by me and dozens of others who abhor violence against women?

Why did the image violate your community standards when I posted it on my page, but does not violate your community standards on another page where it remains even now?

I, and the hundreds of organizations (and thousands of people) who support the Women, Action, & Media (WAM), The Everyday Sexism Project and writer/activist Soraya Chemaly, who have joined forces to have this kind of content removed from Facebook, await an answer.

And we will continue to advocate until Facebook takes action on this issue.

Susan Macaulay created and curates SheQuotesMy Alzheimer’s Story,  Amazing Women, and Succeed With Susan. She is a feminist, global citizen, lifelong learner and the author of Everyday Feminine Wisdom and soon-to-be-published “the dogs’ breakfast.”

29 Responses to “I’m confused Facebook… (Trigger warning)”

  1. mandaray says:

    Reblogged this on Note To Self and commented:
    *sigh* Oh, Facebook. You could be so much more than you are…why do you instead choose to be so Fail?

  2. Rosie says:

    Reblogged this on FEMBORG.

  3. […] notes: on Saturday May 25, at 16:17, I posted an update “I’m confused Facebook…” containing even more irony. Sometime in the hour or so after that post went live, the page on which […]

  4. […] of the links from writers who are angry that Facebook seems happy to take pictures and pages down regarding breastfeeding and other medical issues surrounding breasts, but is happy to leave up images of KKK scarecrows in watermelon fields. Among other […]

  5. […] I’m confused Facebook… (Trigger warning) ( […]

  6. That is disgusting. Shame on facebook.

  7. AmazingSusan says:

    Reblogged this on Amazing Susan a la carte and commented:
    One down, thousands more to go.

  8. Sandra says:

    Glad to see your persistence worked to get the offensive photo removed. Amazing women in action. Way to go!

  9. […] May 25, shortly after I posted “I’m confused Facebook….”, Facebook took down the “tape her at rape her” image for which I was temporarily […]

  10. That picture was brilliant! Haha!

  11. stellamarr says:

    We need to connect the dots between online porn and online sex trafficking profits and advertising — and the big internet companies. I think that might explain some of their behavior. They want as many hits as possible, and as many advertising bucks as possible.

    Thank you for the important work you do drawing attention to this issue. The internet can be magical, but as many of us women are also finding out, its the ideal tool for sociopaths. These big internet companies couldn’t care less, as ‘hits’ mean profits.

    In solidarity and admiration,


  12. […] the Women Action Media group just hopes to see fewer violent images and more users encountering these responses when they upload violent images the first […]

  13. […] I’m confused Facebook… (Trigger warning) […]

  14. […] I’m confused Facebook… (Trigger warning) […]

  15. The Solution says:

    Reblogged this on A Witch Rants.

  16. […] reblogged this post, entitled “I’m Confused Facebook (Trigger Warning)” from the blog, Outside the Box, yesterday. The image of the girl with her mouth taped and the […]

  17. […] my voice heard on the issue of violent misogynist content on Facebook. I blogged about it here, here, here and […]